Thursday, May 31, 2012

The importance of a strong network

I nearly screamed with joy last night.  I had a text from Rose, who had gotten my chapter and would read it as soon as she could...
But she'd recently gotten married and moved and life was a bit in chaos.

I was honestly just thrilled to hear from her and know that she was still involved with the study, even from afar.  I wouldn't say all of the women have become my good friends, but I do feel strongly connected to them in some ways and invested in their lives. It was nice to hear that Rose's story had taken an even more positive turn recently and that she was off on a new adventure.  Even in our interviews, she'd talked about missing the west coast and feeling somewhat stuck and stifled when she returned to the Midwest 6 or 7 years ago, so it was good to hear that she had now moved to the East coast.  A different coast, but a place where she felt like she had opportunities galore.  Her family, of course, stayed here, but I have no doubt that her sisters and parents will stay close in touch.

It was a bit strange getting this message when I did.  I was out to dinner with Angela and Sujin, two of my fellow graduate students, celebrating that the semester was over, that they'd finished their last classes and that Sujin had recently successfully defended her dissertation proposal.  We were talking about passing around IRB information,  reading comp exam essays (for Angela, who will be sitting hers in July), and getting feedback on each other's writing.  It's not exactly a family network, but sometimes it feels like it.  This work can be lonely and sometimes the families that we live with do not understand the process or offer help.  My graduate school "family" is a family formed by similar experiences, past research and writing collaborations, and intellectual interest in each other's topics.  Sujin, Angela, and I have all been interested in language learning, language teaching, and identity development issues.  Reading their work helps drive my own research and build connections between us.

No reading was involved last night, though. Sure, between bites of hummus, Baba Gannoush, Taboleh, falafel and stuffed grape leaves, there was talk of IRB and writing, but we mostly enjoyed the food and the company. It was the first time we'd been able to meet since right before AERA in April.  It was re-energizing to talk about life with others in the midst of this crazy process. We even talked about trying to get tickets to the symphony or go dancing together! While Rose and Amira do keep in contact about their part of the study (as does Ashley), it's the strong network we have of researchers who are at dissertation phase now that keeps me going.

Much like the life stories I've heard, mine, too, speaks of the importance of strong ties to family--even if the most important family at this stage isn't technically my "family" at all.  My family is encouraging, but nothing pushes me quite like hearing "I'm looking forward to reading your conclusions" or "Can you send me your discussion chapter?  I want to see how you ended up doing analysis," or my absolute favorite-- "can I see your finished outline?  I know you're not doing the standard 5 chapter format and I'm thinking about different ways to structure mine as well."  Nothing pushes you to finish quite like that last one!  I don't think I could do this without Sujin, Angela, and Lisa (my advisor), and I'm grateful for their enthusiasm, drive, and company on this journey.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

New Challenges

It's been a productive month, as I finished writing 3 (of my 4) life history chapters in the last 3 weeks.

We also announced my pregnancy this past Sunday--at 12 weeks.  I hope this helps explain some of my quietness for months.  It was on the forefront of my mind and I couldn't talk about it.  I spent a lot of time sick, and even more just plain exhausted.  I'm still trying to recover from the exhaustion, which is tricky with an almost 3 year old in the house who goes through bouts of hating to sleep.  In fact, last night was the first night we had a full night of sleep in over a week. At times, I'm overwhelmed by goals I'd set out, thinking that they're completely realistic, but then I'm frustrated when I cannot, for the life of me, finish them on "schedule."

What does this have to do with a dissertation?  Quite a lot actually.  I'm frustrated and overwhelmed by my last 2 interview transcriptions.  I've hired someone to help with the others, but said that I could do these two.  I NEED to, as one is a core participant (the second interview with the last life history I have to finish) and the other is an interview that is long, but only a small portion really needs to be transcribed as quite a lot doesn't relate to the subject.  We all do our best to leave our personal lives at the door of our work, but the lines inevitably blur.  The lack of sleep catches up to us, as do the worries about finishing a dissertation before a second child arrives.  I also worry about "pregnancy brain" as I continue to write.  Will it be articulate enough?  Will it do justice to my method and my participants' stories?  Which is more important to me--having a good and finished dissertation or having a fantastic dissertation that I can't defend until after the baby is born?  I am leaning towards "good" right now, as I'm terrified of what the first year may have in store for me.

In some ways, being a first time parent in a PhD program was a blessing.  I didn't know how hard it could be.  Had I known what to expect with the reflux, lack of sleep for about a year and a half (between reflux and teething) and how this would interact with my coursework and TA/RA duties, I think I would have quit. This time, I don't just expect it to be the same, but there's no guarantee the baby won't have reflux--and I'll have his or her big brother to contend with, this child who still hates sleeping and isn't a big fan of listening and who we're just praying we can potty train before we take him to preschool part time in the fall.

The reality is this--I have 3 or 3.5 chapters left to write for the full draft, and I want to get them to my committee by the end of August.  I'm tired and while I love what I'm doing, I need to move forward and finish before I get even more overwhelmed.  The chapters to write are: 1) the last life history (which I was able to start during "nap" ("no nap!" struggle time) time yesterday) 2) a chapter of 'analysis'/meaning making (which is at least started) and 3) conclusions/implications, as well as the community interview portion of the "ethos of reception" chapter. The problem is that this would still just make a full draft.  More lit will need to be added, sections will need to be rearranged, etc. Even thinking about this makes me tired some days.  My goal, though, is to simply finish this last core participant interview transcript and life history by the end of May.  June is for the analysis chapter, July is for the conclusions chapter, and the community interview stuff will be done in August, since I have to wait on transcripts for that (and pay my wonderful transcriptionist who's also interested in giving feedback for analysis purposes!  I love working with people who are blossoming researchers and want to be involved in projects!) I'm hoping that a draft in August, with probably a LOT of revisions, will translate to the ability to be able to defend by (or before) October, in order to be "done" before December.  Thanks to a lack of financial aid, I'll have to take credits (but do no work) in the spring though I'll be unofficially finished in December.  UGH.

Did I mention that I'm teaching 3 classes this summer?  One that's fairly intense started yesterday (and it's online).  The students are fantastic and have great questions and ideas,  but I do feel like this will take more energy and time than I think I'd anticipated.

I guess my plea at this point is just for prayer--energy, sleep, and perseverance are all needed at this point.

Monday, April 16, 2012

Reflections on a productive AERA

More than anything, this experience provided me with something more valuable than I can really explain: mental invigoration and energy.  It's almost as if someone said, "you're going about this all wrong.  Here--here's where you start," without ever explicitly saying this.

It was about the comments I got in the workshop.  It was about the questions I was asked to answer during my presentations.  And, more than anything, it was about the rejection I got yesterday for my article.  At first, I was sad.  Really sad.  But then it hit me this morning--I had been framing this portion all wrong.  In fact, I'd been thinking about the dissertation itself all wrong.  I kept trying to think about it as a singular project that needed to use the same methods throughout and see everything in the same light.  I realized that's not what I need to do at all.  It's the same topic and elements, yes, but more like 3 different projects using the same data to get to different aspects of the picture.

In the first portion, I'm exploring newspaper data and community interviews, really focusing on discourse analysis to figure out what the power structures present are and how the larger narratives reaffirm the works of folks like Tehranian (2009), Beyoumi (2008), and Maira (2009), who all state that Muslims have been framed as a monolithic whole, of one mind and thought, looking similarly, and of "the imagined unified region known as the Middle East" (Tehranian).  I'm able to show the shift in focus over time through basic numerical data, as there are far more articles in 2001 on Muslims and Arabs than there were prior.  Though the numbers decrease after 2001, there are still surges in some years such as 2003 (the start of the Iraq War seems to have some impact here) and 2005 (I'm not really sure why on that one!)  and they haven't receded to pre-2001 numbers yet.  Framing has also changed as where "Arab" used to be the primary word of choice (and often used inaccurately in the OP ED pieces I'm looking at), "Muslim" is now more in focus and the words are slightly more likely to occur together  (which indicates to a degree an increased awareness that just because someone is "Arab" doesn't mean that they are Muslim!) Community interviews reveal a divide in knowledge about realities post-9/11 (but as I'm still transcribing these and not yet begun to analyze much, I don't want to say much on this at this point!)

The next section of the project looks at the narratives of my "core" participants.  Using a sort of open coding and grounded theory approach, we've looked for themes similar across the narratives to talk about some important questions and concepts that have come up in the analysis process.  While this, I believe, doesn't do justice to the stories themselves, it's a nice way to summarize findings and raise a few questions.  To better address the stories as a whole and present a less comparative approach, each of these four narratives is presented as a case study of sorts, in narrative inquiry style/methodology.

Finally, and in order to answer the final question ("how do the individual narratives align or disalign with  larger discourses in media and the community?") ...I'm not sure.  This, I think, as I get further into narrative inquiry methods, this may actually be addressed in the case study narratives themselves.

The challenge I was given at the workshop, I think, has become another important question for me to answer in the findings.  One of the other dissertating folks said "I'd love to hear the ways in which these stories and this process has shaped you and your identity/identities."  I really hadn't thought about it before, but I think this is probably the next chapter or portion of a chapter that I start working on as it's been on my mind for the last five days straight :D  As usual, I think the hardest portion will be writing the conclusions and implications.

Like I said, it's almost like it suddenly hit me that this is 3 different projects using the same data and therefore making it seem like a mess from afar, but more like a three dimensional, multi-disiciplinary image as you get down to it.  A challenge to create, for sure, but it's become an important creation for me as I hope to help others from multiple understandings within education perceive the importance and complexity of the issues I'm trying to address.

I'd love to hear any other thoughts/questions out there!  As it stands, the intro is done (with some more lit review to be worked on/added, of course), and the newspaper/community interview chapter is about half finished.  I have 3 of the 4 narratives drafted though still in progress, and I'm honestly hoping to get to work on the findings now.  No, I know I'm not "done" with the analysis, but there are things that keep coming up and need to be addressed for sure, even if I end up having to scrap it later because it no longer seems accurate at the end. With any luck, I'll have a draft at least of everything by July :D It is happening and it will happen.  It's such a good feeling to come home from the conference and realize I'm actually sort of closer than I thought I was to finishing!

Friday, April 13, 2012

Vancouver

Again, it's not dissertation related, but hit me so hard tonight as I'm here to present my research that I have to share this.

Vancouver

At the conference center,
Abuzz with excitement,
Talk of measurement
Evaluation
Social contexts of learning
And social justice,

I am awed
By the mountains
‘cross the water
and the breeze
that drifts by
as hydroplanes
swoop down
and gulls glide by
and all seems still

people stop
at coffee bars
at department stores
at art galleries
awed by beauty,
enjoying their freedom
in the midst
of conference talk
and business talk
and busy talk

I walk
Out the doors,
Up five blocks
And turn on Granville
Towards my hotel

It doesn’t take long
Before the scenery changes
The busy streets
And shops
And happy people
Are still there
But every few feet, every block
Someone is lying down

Under an awning
On a heated grate
By a bus shelter
The first man I pass along the way
Is sleeping, as he was when I walked by this morning.
I know it’s the same man, though I never see his face
His clothes are the same.
Black pants, black hoodie pulled up, and curled almost into a ball.
He doesn’t beg.

The next man is sitting next to a store
 by the entrance and singing
The next is a group of drummers
 sitting next to a store entry and working together in rhythm.
This feels more like the indie music scene
I was told about in this neighborhood
But I know it’s not quite.
I see their clear plastic starbucks cups
And the sign that says “please”

I walk by the old theaters,
The symphony,
The giant record store across the street
People are talking, laughing,
Dressed for concerts
Walking quickly
By people sitting quiet, dirty, with cups
Signs that say “any change will help”
And no one seems to see them
And I just can’t get over the contrasts,
The disparities I’m seeing.

Then I’m on the block I hate.
The one that breaks my heart,
As I see him again.
The kind boy with the dark hair
And beautiful dark eyes.
He talks quietly to each person that passes by
“Please, miss, do you have any change?”
I say yesterday that I’m from out of town and have no cash
(It’s true.  I didn’t take any out and don’t have a debit card with me)
“A penny even?”
“not even that,” I smile at him sadly.

Today, I can’t even look.
I know he won’t remember me,
But I see his face,
Hear his quiet desperation
His kind words to all those who walk by
Most don’t even acknowledge that he’s there.

Then something worse happens.
Something I can’t really believe.
I hear a clanging sound ahead of me
And notice a man,
Sitting under the bus stop awning
With his clear starbucks cup
Sprawled several feet in front of him.
They at least sort of stop to say “sorry.”
She says “oh. Sorry,”
and he says, “yeah, she’s sorry.”
And they keep walking
Never stopping to help.

After the boy,
and not having any change to give  him myself
I stoop and scoop
And he says “thank you miss”
Over and over
And I just say quietly,
“I can’t believe they didn’t stop to help”
“I can’t believe it either.  I’m 64 years old and I can’t believe it either.”
We don’t talk after that, just attend to the work
Another girl stops to help
And we leave when we’re done.

His cup was mostly full of pennies,
with a few nickels
and one quarter that I saw
I can almost justify the young boy on the street.
Teenage runaway, perhaps?
But the 64-year-old man,
Who wasn’t yelling like some of the other street people
Or talking to himself
And just kept thanking us for helping
What’s the reason he’s there?
No one who’s old enough to be a grandfather
Deserves to be on the street.
Where are their families?

Downtown, all is beautiful
Especially by the Harbor
And where the Olympic buildings are
Gastown tells the story of a booming drug traffic,
But only in certain parks and on corners
Most tourists wouldn’t see

Yorktown and the Granville neighborhood
Where I walk to
Back to my room
Tell a different story
The story I was compelled to tell here
Of how easily
People become invisible
And how even in moments they are visible
When the coins spill
Most people choose to let them become invisible again.

I never thought I’d leave Vancouver
With a heavy heart
And a lasting impression
Of the sadness in this city
Instead of the conference
But I think this is what will follow me home.

Hopefully tomorrow, if I see the boy,
I’ll remember to stop and ask if I can get him food
I may not have cash
But I still have power to notice
And to respond
To human need. 

Thursday, April 5, 2012

I'm sorry

To those that subscribe,
A post that never should have been posted publicly was apparently sent to all of you as part of my blog.  I sincerely apologize for this, as it was a rough day and I was trying to "write out" my frustrations, having no idea anyone else would see them.

I guess sometimes a bad day kicks you twice, and words even on paper live to haunt you another day.

Let the dissertation work continue post haste--and say a prayer that it's finished by mid to late fall!  I head to AERA and two days of workshops next week to tweak and refine, sans family.  I am hopeful that it's productive and rejuvenating for all of us.

Friday, March 9, 2012

Pray without Ceasing

This deviates somewhat from the dissertation itself, but when you think about writing as my form of prayer, it's not too far off (dissertation as prayer, blogging as prayer). What follows is probably a disorderly mess of thoughts, but I had to "put pen to paper" as soon as I stepped out of the shower this morning.  I had a revelation of the sort that only interaction with my son can bring, but I'll get to more of that later.

In 1 Thessalonians 5:17, we are encouraged to "pray without ceasing," and for the longest time I couldn't fathom it.

As a child, I always thought of prayer as communal or at the very least, "heads bowed, eyes closed." Trying to combine this and praying without ceasing resulted in me running into a few walls while walking, a few puzzled looks from others watching this, and a heart-felt exasperation that to pray without ceasing must mean one must become a monk or nun (I didn't know at the time that Monks and nuns had tasks in a monastery outside of prayers). When I was in later elementary school and began singing in choirs and writing my own songs, I heard from members of my congregation, "that's such a beautiful prayer."  Oh!  I thought--prayer can be in words that don't require me to lose my bearings and run into things?  I spent much of my middle school years singing whenever I could (which probably explains why I was nicknamed "Opera lady" by a classmate and found myself alone a lot!)

High school and adolescence changed things.  I didn't feel like praying or singing for a long time and when I did, I found solace in quiet places. My flute music was my prayer as my mom battled a scary diagnosis, and it said "thank you" the doctors shook their heads and decided that the original diagnosis was wrong.  I ran into the woods at Durley camp with a couple of friends to climb and swing and sing a quiet prayer or two when cliques and rumors overwhelmed me.  I stopped praying my junior year when the color drained from my world, one of my favorite mentors passed away, and I felt God calling me away from music and into something else (I still think about "Aunt" Harriet Whiteman constantly and how she may have shaped my calling in many ways).  I started dreaming dreams of about a new calling, but was scared--if I prayed through my music and it was being taken away from me, how would I pray? How could I let God know how heartbroken I was and how much I needed him when he'd taken my voice from me?

It happened in inches and in miles, really.  My voice returned to a degree, and my love of music and new calling combined in strange ways.  IYC 2000 in Colorado was, in retrospect, one of the most important events of my life.  It was there (or on the way, actually) that I met Josh and Chris.  Like me, Josh had been raised on "old school" CCM, but felt called to be a computer programmer.  It was a passion and gift--as was his ability to play the piano and sing Keith Green songs.  Even to this day, though I remember him (and Chris) trying to explain to me RPGs and what it was like to program for them, it's the Keith Green songs that we shared that stick with me: "Oh God, though I have wandered so far, you know that I'm still a man after your own heart."  He'd managed to combine a love of music (and music as prayer) with his calling, so why couldn't I?  It was strange that in the year to come, I was able to go on a music ministry and ESL teaching missions trip to Japan.  These kind of combinations don't happen often--and it was there that I fell in love with ESL and really felt called, both to teach and to minister through working with immigrants.

And still the Keith Green song stuck with me, appearing out of nowhere in my thoughts and acting as a prayer often my freshman year of college.  As I discovered "The Celebration of Discipline" that year, focused on fasting and new forms of prayer (laying down and taking up), I started seeing how prayer was intertwined into the lives and regular actions of my professors and developing in the lives of friends I made at college.  It's a strange thing when it finally clicks, that prayer is how we live.

 True, Leopold Weiss' words from yesterday help--that he saw in the Muslims he met that life and prayer and vocation couldn't be separated as words of prayer and relational words to God were a part of everything they did, but this isn't often how we teach or model prayer for our children.

And yet, T (my 2 1/2 year old) seems to have picked this up.  We have said prayers with him since he was about 2 months old, but it's only been lately as he's had more words that we've asked him who he would like to pray for.  He now has his list ready, happily and overflowing from his mouth.  Some people are listed repeatedly, and I often have wondered if he's just delaying sleep and ask if he's done.  We say "Amen" and call it a night.  This morning was different.  This morning, in the shower, he started in with his prayer list.  I have to admit,  I was a bit shocked.  Was he not making the connection to the names and when we pray?

But I think he knows better than I do sometimes.  He already seems to understand that we can pray anytime, anywhere, out loud, in our heads, in our music or even in our computer programs (buttons!) or teaching. He's learned that prayer without ceasing is possible and does not have to be an awkward interjection into our lives, but should be the outpouring of our thoughts and feelings to God--it is a life well lived with caring and concern for others, full of thanks and praise for the gifts we've been given, and joy for the journey he has given us.

I'm learning how to pray without ceasing from my 2 year old--even if he is a hyper-active teacher.

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Who I am and who I was called to be...

A good friend had a wise word today--that who I am is enough and that the focus should be upon whose I am and knowing that I'm loved.


This, my friends, may be true but is no easy feat.  Meetings, writing, demands on energy from family, work and even within the church can be a difficult balance and all the while it's about the tension between academia and being a person of faith.  Kathleen Norris, in addressing a college community last year, explained the friction this way:


I’ve heard Benedictine men and women, scholars who are members of the American Academy of Religion talk about their reluctance to discuss their life of faith in an academic setting, even with their own students. But at least they’re monastics, kind of exotic: pity the ordinary, garden-variety Christian! 
The writer Patricia Hampl once said that when other professors discovered she was a practicing Catholic, their estimation of her IQ took a noticeable drop. A few years ago, I was at a reception after a talk I’d presented, and became aware that my co-sponsors, the literature and religion faculties, were in a marriage of convenience that made both groups ill-at-ease. During one conversation, a professor said, “Sometimes I think it would be good to do away with all religions.” It had been a very long day for me, or I probably wouldn’t have replied so starkly; but I said, “You know, Joseph Stalin and Pol Pot tried that, and it didn’t work out so well.” I’m convinced that having some historical grounding, and some sense of how religious traditions have functioned in human history, for both good and ill, is essential to understanding how they might shape our own vocation, a life of hope and meaning.  

To be doing this project at a secular university is both the best and worst of both worlds.  It is geared towards a wider audience, centered on human development, bioecological theory and a particular time in history.  It also (attempts to) present religion as important and truth-bearing, though this hasn't always been understood, I think, even by those at the University. This is the most difficult part to me--to attempt justification of this study to my community of faith (as something more than just my thoughts) and to a university (to many, it's simply another phenomena).  

To me, it's a defining piece of who I am and why I am writing this dissertation--to acknowledge that faith and prayer are alive in my generation, and not just among those who tow a particular political line.  This is a prayer whispered that faith and intelligence do not have to be separated.  As Norris states the Benedictine monks told her, "sometimes writing IS your prayer."  It's what connects me to texts that are thousands of years old and draws me into a conversation between millions of people over time.  It's why Norris, L'Engle, Leopold Weiss, Dr. Hamid, C.S. Lewis and other voices I run across seem to speak in harmony, despite coming out of different faiths and different times in history.  
Leopold Weiss (later known as Muhammad Asad), in his journey from Judaism to Islam, states in a bold revelation: " It was at this moment that I became aware how near their God and their faith were to these people. Their prayer did not seem to be divorced from their working day; it was part of it ñ not meant to help them forget life, but to remember it better by remembering God."

I guess, in many ways, this answers my earlier question about being Alyosha or Ivan.  I'm called--as are others-- to be BOTH, or at least not see the intellectual working portion of myself as separate from the praying, faithful (often frazzled mom) and loving child of God.  

This ability to weave faith and thought together, I believe, is what I was meant to share.  It's what all four of my "core" participants do so well, and what some of the community members have done as well.  If I can do this, well, it is enough.  My work IS enough and I don't have to feel like my analysis isn't quantitative enough or "churchy" enough.  It is what I was called to do and I can simply hope that the prayer that flows from my fingers is as beautiful, awe-filled, hopeful and loving as it sounds in my head. 

May we all be one in the bonds of love...and for heaven's sake, may I move forward with the analysis phase (being stuck inside my own head isn't much fun of late). 

References
Asad, Muhammad () "The Road to Mecca."  Adaptation from Islamland (a PDF gifted from one of my participants).

Norris, Kathleen (2011, March).  "Shaping a life that matters."  NETvue Conference, Indianapolis, IN.

Weiss, Leopold